By Ray 'Sleeves' Okafor · Edited by Mona Trell

Listen · Ray 'Sleeves' Okafor reads this piece · 1:48

Every person who ever bought a jigsaw puzzle from me got asked the same question by whoever they doing it with: edge pieces first or nah?

And every time, somebody at that table gonna say 'Obviously edge first, that's how you do puzzles.'

Like it's a law.
Like the International Puzzle Federation gonna show up at your house if you start in the middle.

I asked one guy, why. He looked at me like I asked why gravity. 'Because the frame,' he said. 'Gotta see what you working with.'

That ain't just a method.
That's a whole cognitive approach you learned once at age seven and been defending at Thanksgiving ever since.

Turns out researchers been studying this. Not the edge-first versus chaos argument specifically, because academia got better things to do than settle your dining room disputes. But they did study what happens in the brain when adults sit down with jigsaw puzzles, and the findings explain why some folk can't start a puzzle without an organizational system and some folk just grab whatever piece got the most blue on it.

What The Science Actually Measured About Puzzle Solving Strategy

A German research team recruited a hundred cognitively healthy adults, all fifty or older, and split them into two groups. The jigsaw puzzle group got thirty days of mandatory puzzle time, at least one hour a day, plus four sessions of general cognitive health counseling. The control group just got the counseling and probably wondered what they did wrong.

Before and after, the researchers measured eight different visuospatial cognitive abilities: perception, constructional praxis, mental rotation, processing speed, cognitive flexibility, working memory, reasoning and episodic memory. They averaged all eight scores into one number they called 'global visuospatial cognition,' which is science talk for 'how good your brain is at dealing with shapes, spaces and where the hell things go.'

Then they gave everybody a forty-piece untrained puzzle and timed how fast they finished it. That score, puzzle skill, correlated with every single one of those eight abilities. The correlation was strong. We talking r-values at or above 0.45 for each measure, and a combined correlation of 0.80 for the whole visuospatial package.

Translation: people who good at puzzles also good at a whole bunch of other brain tasks that involve seeing, rotating, remembering and manipulating objects in space.
People who bad at puzzles probably real annoying to move furniture with.

The Edge First Puzzle Method Is A Chunking Move

Now the edge-first puzzle solving strategy, the one everybody swear by like it came down from Mount Sinai, that's what cognitive science call chunking. You taking a big overwhelming problem and breaking it into smaller managed pieces. Literally.

You find the edges, you build the frame, now you got a container. Now the middle ain't infinite no more. It got borders. You reduced the problem space. You turned chaos into a geography.

The random-piece-first people, they doing something different. They working off pattern recognition, color matching, trial and error. Both methods work. Both get you to a finished puzzle. But they recruit different cognitive pathways to get there, and both sides think the other side doing it wrong.

Hand holding puzzle piece up to examine it closely

The chunking folks, they front-loading the organizational work. They spending time up front to make the back end easier. Classic delayed gratification. Very responsible. Very Type A.

The pattern folks, they diving straight into the visual matching and letting the structure emerge as they go. Living in the moment. Vibing with the puzzle. Probably forgot where they put the box lid.

Neither one wrong.
Your brain just picked a lane sometime around third grade and been riding it ever since.

And before somebody write me about advanced jigsaw puzzle solving techniques: the study didn't measure strategy type. They measured skill, experience and cognitive outcomes. I'm connecting the dots here, which is funny given the subject, but the chunking research exist in other contexts and the edge-first method fit the definition clean.

Thirty Days Don't Do Much, Thirty Years Do

The intervention group, the folks who did daily puzzles for a month, they didn't show significant improvement in global visuospatial cognition compared to the control group. Effect size was -0.08, which in research terms mean 'basically nothing happened.'

Negative zero point zero eight.
That's not even a rounding error. That's a measurement artifact with delusions.

But lifetime puzzle experience? That was a whole different story. The people who been doing jigsaw puzzles for years, they scored significantly higher on visuospatial measures than people who don't puzzle. The relationship was strong enough that the researchers called it 'a potential protective factor for cognitive aging.'

Potential. Not proven. Not a cure. Not a guarantee. A observed association in a hundred people that need way more study before anybody start promising miracles in a cardboard box.

What it do tell us is that the brain you got at seventy is partly shaped by what you been doing since you was forty. You can't cram for cognition. This ain't a test you study for the night before. This ain't something you fix with a weekend intensive and a motivational poster.

One month of jigsaw puzzle solving hacks ain't rewiring decades of neural architecture. But decades of pulling puzzles off the shelf might actually be doing something, and the data suggest it's something good.

The Limitation Nobody Mention At The Dinner Table

Sample size: a hundred people. Intervention period: thirty days. Assessment: one forty-piece puzzle and a battery of cognitive tests. Control for motivation, prior experience, education level and what folk been doing the other twenty-three hours a day? Partial at best.

This study show association. It don't show causation. Maybe puzzles make your brain better at visuospatial tasks. Maybe people with strong visuospatial skills just like puzzles more and do them more often. Maybe it's both. Maybe it's something else entirely we ain't even thought of yet, like childhood access to Legos or growing up in a house with stairs.

The researchers know this. They called for more study. They published a protocol paper two years before the results, laid out exactly what they was measuring and why, let the whole world see the method before the data came in. That's how you supposed to do it. That's scientific integrity, and it's rare enough that I gotta point at it when I see it.

What they didn't do is promise that buying a jigsaw puzzle gonna prevent neurocognitive disorders. And neither am I.

What This Mean For The Folks At Your Table

If you the type who gotta sort every piece before you start, that ain't obsessive. That's a cognitive strategy your brain like. You chunking. You organizing. You controlling variables. You the same person who alphabetize your spice rack and nobody mad at you for it.

If you the type who grab a random piece and just start fitting things together, you ain't doing it wrong. You using pattern recognition and visual memory, and them skills matter too. You also the person who can pack a car trunk like Tetris, so you got value.

The best way to start a jigsaw puzzle is whatever way keep you at the table long enough to finish it. Because the data suggest it's the years of engagement that might matter, not the method you use to engage.

I had a lady come in last month, bought a two-thousand-piece landscape, told me she do one every winter. Been doing it for forty years. She don't sort nothing. Just dump the box and go. Chaos incarnate.

Her brain been getting that visuospatial workout for four decades.
I don't think she need my jigsaw puzzle tips.

The folk who might need them is the folk who bought a puzzle five years ago, did half of it, put it back in the box and ain't touched one since. That ain't a cognitive intervention. That's a decoration for your coffee table and a source of low-level guilt every time you walk past it.

Consistency over intensity. That's what the research show. Not thirty days of forced daily puzzle time that you resent, but thirty years of doing it because you like it and it beat watching the news.

Which, funny enough, is the same thing that work for damn near every other skill we ever measured.
Turns out you can't hack mastery.
You just gotta show up.

This article is education and reporting on published research. It is not medical advice, and nothing here is intended to diagnose, treat, cure or prevent any disease. Talk to your own clinician about your own situation.

Sources

  1. Jigsaw Puzzling Taps Multiple Cognitive Abilities and Is a Potential Protective Factor for Cognitive Aging, Frontiers in aging neuroscience (2018).
  2. Jigsaw Puzzles As Cognitive Enrichment (PACE) - the effect of solving jigsaw puzzles on global visuospatial cognition in adults 50 years of age and older: study protocol for a randomized controlled trial, Trials (2017).
  3. Video Game Training Enhances Visuospatial Working Memory and Episodic Memory in Older Adults, Frontiers in human neuroscience (2016).

Leave a comment

This site is protected by hCaptcha and the hCaptcha Privacy Policy and Terms of Service apply.